News

Why Uncle Sam Really Hates Cash

The Federal Reserve’s just-launched FedNow payment network is the first step on the road to transforming the U.S. into an entirely cashless economy. Today, we ask whether that’s a bureaucrat’s dream come true, or a dystopian nightmare – or could it be both?

From Peter Reagan at Birch Gold Group

Created by the Federal Reserve, the FedNow instant payment system went operational on July 20, 2023.

If you’ve ever sent a wire, ACH or e-check through a bank, and were frustrated that it took up to five business days to clear, that problem may be solved. At least, that’s what the Fed’s description of the service says:

It is available to depository institutions in the United States and enables individuals and businesses to send instant payments through their depository institution accounts. The service is a flexible, neutral platform that supports a broad variety of instant payments. At the most fundamental level, the service provides interbank clearing and settlement that enables funds to be transferred from the account of a sender to the account of a receiver in near real-time and at any time, any day of the year.

Has U.S. banking finally moved into the 21st century?

Maybe so. But like any service developed by federal institutions, there’s likely a lot more going on under the surface.

We’ll discuss that in just a moment. First we need a brief glance at the ways money moves through the economy, and recent trends.

Ch-ch-changes in cash

It’s safe to say the U.S. financial system, despite its place at the center of the global economy, is lagging behind the times.

For comparison purposes, Australia is experimenting with a major economic shift right now. One of Australia’s biggest banks quietly stopped dispensing cash at a number of its branches. ANZ Worldline Payment Solutions chief market officer Anne McDonnell claimed that, in Australia, cash is fading fast:

As consumers become accustomed to digital and even invisible payments – think transport apps automatically taking care of payment – they increasingly regard making physical payments as an inconvenience.

Now, “making physical payments” may indeed be “an inconvenience,” but does that mean cash itself is equally inconvenient? I’d argue no. Rather, cash is “an inconvenience” for some retailers, especially those employing cashiers who can’t do math. By the same logic, shopping with local independent retailers is “an inconvenience,” though it’s one I personally don’t mind in the least. The superior service I get is well worth the inconvenience.

That’s my way of saying it’s a mistake to equate “inconvenience” with “obsolescence.”

Let’s turn to Jim Rickards, who summarized developments down under. He ends with an important question:

Over the past year, $1 billion in bank notes have been removed from circulation in Australia. And according to a March bulletin from the Reserve Bank of Australia, the percentage of retail payments settled in cash fell from 70% in 2007 to 27% in 2019.

That number is even lower today, as COVID further eased the transition away from cash in 2020. Remember when they were telling us to avoid cash because it might be carrying the virus?

Well, as of last year, the percentage of Australian retail payments settled in cash fell to just 13%. How long will it be before cash payments are eliminated altogether? [emphasis added]

How long, indeed. It’s quite possible that Australia’s economy is moving out of physical cash already. Just consider the incentives from a retailer’s perspective:

  • No more daily visits from the Brinks armored car
  • Faster checkout (no more counting pennies or fumbling for exact change)
  • Reduced incentive for armed robbery
  • An end to the daily audit of every cash register’s drawer
  • Enhanced tracking, profiling and surveillance opportunities

This is a prime opportunity for the Australian government to issue a digital currency to replace cash.

Consider the benefits from a government’s perspective:

  • Just think of all the money saved on postage!
  • Eliminates tax avoidance from “cash under the table” income
  • Enhanced tracking, profiling and surveillance opportunities

Before you get too comfortable, I should warn you things are shifting in the U.S. too.

Take a look at the chart below. You can clearly see how cash use has been slowly declining as a form of payment:

The report offered one interesting insight into the future of cash:

If these consumers did not shift away from using cash amidst the conditions of the early pandemic, it is less likely that they will shift their payment behavior in the future; barring another major event occurring. [emphasis added]

But therein lies the problem. The Federal Reserve has been operating in emergency mode since 2007. The Fed already predicted a potential financial crisis in 2023. A few media outlets are trying to stir a new wave of hysteria over the latest Covid-19 variant, EG.5 or “Eris.” At least ten more regional banks are on deathwatch...

All this means a “major event” could happen at any time. There’s always a crisis somewhere, according to the Fed.

With the FedNow payment system already established, that would make it much easier for the government to eliminate cash in favor of a digital replacement like FedCoin.

To quote Perry Mason, "Cui bono?" Who benefits from the switch to a cashless economy?

Why does Uncle Sam hate cash?

Thanks to blockchain tech, the Fed has been talking about the implementation of a digital currency for quite some time.

We’ve covered “why” the Federal Government wants to move away from physical cash in a previous article, which basically boils down to control:

Why does the federal bureaucracy hate cash? It’s private and it’s untraceable. Essentially, cash is one of the few remaining bastions of financial privacy. I say “privacy” rather than “secrecy” on purpose – “privacy” means enforcing your personal boundaries and what you’re comfortable sharing. “Secrecy” means intentionally hidden information.

Rickards illustrated what that control might look like if the U.S. were to move into a cashless society:

In reality, the so-called “cashless society” is just a Trojan horse for a system in which all financial wealth is electronic and represented digitally in the records of a small number of megabanks and asset managers.

Once that is achieved, it will be easy for state power to seize and freeze the wealth, or subject it to constant surveillance, taxation and other forms of digital confiscation like negative interest rates. [emphasis added]

Slowly, then suddenly, you could find yourself an inmate in a digital financial panopticon. Surveillance is the first step in control. And let’s face it – a digital dollar only exists at the whim of the Federal Reserve and the federal government.

Let’s hope that dystopia never comes to pass, because it would be the end of economic freedom.

What’s the likelihood?

Ask yourself, when has the federal government ever reduced its own authority and power?

Keeping some cash on hand seems like the easiest solution – at least for now.

But for when cash gets canceled, we’ll still have one form of physical currency…

Here’s what happens when cash is really trash

The “good” news is, the going-cashless experiment backfired miserably when India's government tried it back in 2016:

The immediate fallout was chaos, as the country scrambled to cope. There was a rush at banks and ATMs to exchange old notes and withdraw new currency. Queues at banks grew; many people suffered, especially the poor, who had no access to credit cards or mobile wallets; and dozens of deaths resulting from the crisis were reported.

Two years later, the dust has settled, and it has become obvious that demonetization was not the resounding success the government expected it to be… The economy has taken a beating, huge financial losses have been incurred, and the marginalized poor, least able to withstand adversity, have been negatively affected.

Of course, this isn’t good news for the individuals who had to survive the massive financial fallout from the government’s experiment. An economic crisis of unimaginable proportions wracked the nation – which is only “good news” as far as it warns other nations not to repeat this mistake.

Fortunately, there’s even better news…

There’s ONE form of money that's both universally valued and immune to cancellation by overzealous bankers or government officials. Better still, it’s unprintable and uninflatable – and it still exists whether or not you have WiFi. Even when the lights go out.

Whether or not the U.S. goes cashless in the future, diversifying your savings with physical gold and silver may be smart. You might even want to keep some on hand, just in case.

Gold has been recognized as money for thousands of years, and central banks keep adding more to their reserves. That's because they know that precious metals have intrinsic value (their value is based on their utility as well as supply and demand), so they tend to retain their value over time.

You can get all the information you need about both gold and silver for free to make an informed decision right here.

BGG - CTA Option 2

Get Your Free 2024 Gold IRA Information Kit

Name(Required)

By submitting this form, you agree to receive automated text messages. This agreement is not a condition of any purchases. Msg & Data rates may apply. Reply STOP at any time to unsubscribe.